Friday, February 10, 2012

Quiet: a look at Introversion

QUIET: The Power of Introverts in a World That Can’t Stop Talking / Susan Cain
Crown, 2012.
352 p.

What do I really need to say about this book? It has launched itself into the world with a huge celebratory splash! I've been seeing Susan Cain interviewed, reading about her and about this book and hearing people talking about the very important issues she has illuminated. And I don't believe that any of this is any more than what is justly deserved by this marvellous, thorough, and inspiring read.

I suppose I should start by saying that I am an introvert, and have always known that and been comfortable with it. However, others have not always been so comfortable, something that I know other introverted friends have also had to deal with. "Why are you sitting there reading? Go outside and play with the other kids." I heard that a few times, certainly. Or, "You've got to be more outgoing and improve your customer service skills", which I've also heard, and which in this context meant, be louder, more smiley, more chatty with the complete strangers who you come into contact with. Nothing to do with actually providing the service that the customer was asking for.

Thankfully those days are in my past. But experiences like this are reason enough for me to strongly, fervently recommend this book to everyone. Yes, EVERYONE. Parents, bosses, friends, coworkers, teachers, partners -- everyone. Introverts may come to a better understanding of themselves and find words to describe their experiences more clearly. Extroverts may come to a better understanding of the introverts in their lives and not be so determined to make everyone else comply to their preferences.

Susan Cain has created a very complete look at the way introverts are limited in our extrovert-focused society. She breaks the book up into specific themes; work, parenting, social life, and so on, and explores how introverts experience these things according to their personality preferences and how their preferences are often discounted or criticized because they aren't the extrovert preference. She is careful to point out that there is nothing inherently "better" or "worse" about either introversion or extroversion -- but that the Extrovert Ideal dominates our society and makes it difficult for many introverts to feel comfortable expressing who they are. The basic difference between the two lies in the way that each is energized -- introverts are drained by too much stimulation and recharge by spending time alone in a quiet setting, while extroverts feel understimulated by too much quiet, alone time and like to recharge themselves with lots of stimulation, whether physical activity, noise, or lots of other people. Shyness is a separate trait altogether, even if it is often confused with the idea of being introverted. Cain notes that a shy extrovert has it very tough: wanting to energize around other people but being afraid of social judgement (shyness).

I've read a number of books about introversion, but I particularly enjoyed this one because Cain is a really good writer who has created a book that flows, and enlightens in an entertaining manner. She explores super-extroverted settings like the gigantic American Saddleback Church, or a Tony Robbins seminar, and explains her points with plenty of fun anecdotes AND plenty of scientific studies to back them all up.

The key statement of this book is that introverts have valuable personality traits that shouldn't be discounted or ignored any longer. Cain compares the situation of introverts (who make up anywhere from 1/3 to 1/2 of the population) to that of women at the start of the feminist movement: their talents and skills were being suppressed and wasted under the masculine ideal, and she sees the state of introverts today as similar to this. With the current organizational structure of education, the workplace and social expectations all fostering the ideal of charisma, personality, togetherness and appearance, introverts have to struggle to keep up and spend much of their energy on coping strategies. Not to mention that they begin to discount their own specific personality and preferences.

The value of this book at this moment is that it has opened up a lively discussion of its themes, without the derogatory judgements of introversion that I've heard so often. Perhaps we are just ready for it, perhaps as Cain notes, our society shows some signs of looking for a quieter, less frenetic state of being. Or perhaps I've just been missing those conversations ;) I think that this is an important book, one which should be read by policy makers, by businesspeople and managers, by extroverts who need a little illumination. Introverts may have different preferences than those expressed by the 'norms' of the work world, but the introverted worldview, once given the space to flourish, may change everything.

Read this. Be illuminated. Change the world!


  1. I liked this a lot too, especially for the way she blended the anecdotes with the science. I had a few minor quibbles with the way introversion was conflated with other qualities (like sensitivity) when Cain herself says they don't always go together. What I've liked the most is the conversation it's sparked. I'm mostly comfortable with my introversion too, but it's still good to see people being made aware of how some of society's expectations can be damaging to introverts (and to society itself).

  2. I am waiting for this to come in for me at the library. I am glad you liked it. :)

  3. My library just got this in and a coworker grabbed it off my cart! It looks good and it sounds good, too. I am the bad combination--shy introvert. It's sort of sucky as I think people think I am standoffish or aloof and get the wrong idea, when that is not the case at all--I just don't want to look a fool and when things come out they usually come out all wrong! I'll have to get ahold of this one!

  4. Teresa - I agree completely. I'm not 'sensitive' either but know some who are. I think the conversation that's arisen around it is fantastic.

    Kailana - I read it in ebook format and am waiting for the library copy to come in so I can put it on display! :)

    Danielle - I think you'll like it. It's great at explaining that introvert does not = shy/stuck up/misanthropic, etc. All those things that you've probably heard as well....

  5. I think I'm going to have to pick this one up! It's only in the past few years that I've realized that I'm an introvert. Just because I'm outgoing and am comfortable talking to anyone (thus don't have the normal "appearance" of an introvert), I now see that I am one because of the way I'm energized. It's also the reason why I get so annoyed with my kids at bedtime. "This is when you're supposed to leave mommy alone to finally have peace and quiet!" It will be particularly interesting to read the part on parenthood. THanks for another great review!

  6. I am one of a long list of hold requests for this at my library. I am very much looking forward to reading it and so glad that it and introverts are getting so much attention!

  7. Dixie - I'm glad you can see yourself in it - I think it's important for any introvert to know our preferences and not try to be something else. Cain makes it clear that introverted personalities can be very different from each other as well -- some shy, some quite outgoing. It's all in the energizing preferences.

    Stefanie - I hope you'll like it once you finally get your hands on it! I'm pleased by how much discussion I've been hearing about it; I just hope some of the people who I think *need* to read it will do so!

  8. This book sounds fascinating! I'll have to check it out. I love books that mix science with great storytelling techniques. I'm also an introvert (a shy one, though less so now than in the past).


Thanks for stopping by ~ I always enjoy hearing your comments so please feel free to leave some!